Is an old slate roof worth repairing?
Very often, yes. The Confederation of Roofing Contractors gives well-kept slate a life of 100+ years. The slate itself is rarely what gives up first. The iron nails that hold it rust through, individual slates slip, and lead dressed round stacks, up walls and along valleys thins with age. Slate that is sound but has lost its fixings can be lifted, refixed and put back. Slate that is cracked or flaking is replaced with matching pieces, taken from the same roof where we can, for instance from a rear slope that nobody sees.
Repair wins when the battens and rafters under the slate are firm. We check them from the loft and show you photographs of what we find, whether that is dry timber or a soft, dark patch beneath a leaking valley. If they are failing, we tell you plainly and explain why patching the slate would be money wasted. Our pitched roofing page sets out how we work on slate and tile roofs, from a single slipped slate to a full re-cover.
At the survey we also run along the gutters, the fascia boards behind them and the lead dressed around any chimney. A small gap in one of those can mimic a failed slate on the ceiling inside, so we trace the water back to where it actually gets in before we put a price on anything. Daylight in the loft, a damp batten and a stained rafter tell the story faster than guesswork from the ground.