The short answer
No. Ridge tiles can be bedded in mortar with mechanical fixings, or held entirely by a dry ridge system with no mortar at all. What matters is that every tile has a mechanical fixing, because a mortar bed is no longer left to hold ridge tiles by itself. Neither method is forbidden, and BS 5534 is a code to work to, not an Act of Parliament.
The three ways a ridge can be fixed, what BS 5534 and BS 8612 say about them, and how to choose for your own roof.
Three ways to fix a ridge
Ridge tiles sit along the crest, over the joint between the two slopes. There are three common ways to hold those tiles on. The first is the older method: tiles bedded on mortar with nothing else. The second is mortar plus mechanical fixings, where clips, screws or straps hold each tile and the mortar mainly fills and seals the joints. The third is a dry ridge: a batten along the top, fixings through or over it, and a roll or strip that seals and ventilates, with no mortar bed at all.
Each has its place. Mortar-only ridges still exist on a great many older roofs, and they work until the bed cracks. The other two systems are the ones now recommended for new work and repairs. A dry ridge also has no wet trade, so it can be fitted in cold or damp weather that would spoil mortar. Our page on what a dry ridge system is (the dry ridge page) shows the parts and how they fit together.
What BS 5534 and BS 8612 say
BS 5534 is the code of practice for pitched roofs covered in slates or tiles, and BSI lists the 2014 edition with its 2018 amendment as current. BSI cautions that some of it may not suit an old roof built from traditional or salvaged materials. The practical effect for ridges is that mortar is not relied upon alone to resist wind, so tiles set in a bed are expected to be clipped or screwed down as well, whether they sit at the ridge or along a hip. Marley, a tile maker, says the same about the 2014 revision.
BS 8612 sets out the tests that a manufacturer's dry ridge, dry hip and dry verge systems are put through, and it is how a maker shows a product has been properly assessed. Nothing in law forces a roofer to follow BS 5534, so a mortar ridge is not unlawful and nobody should tell you it is. It is, though, the standard a careful roofer works to, so ask which one will be used on your roof and why. A clear answer is a good sign of a clear quote.
When mortar is still the right call
On some roofs, mortar with fixings is the better answer. A period house with irregular, reclaimed or handmade ridge tiles may not suit a standard dry system, because the fittings are made for regular profiles. A conservation area or listed building may call for a traditional look, so check with the council's planning team before the ridge is altered, and ask your roofer to photograph the existing tiles so the new ones can follow their shape. Some owners simply prefer the finish of a bedded ridge, and on a short run with sound tiles that is a reasonable choice. The key is that the tiles are secured to the roof and not just stuck to each other, whatever the system.
If you keep mortar, the bed should still sit over mechanical fixings, be mixed correctly and be laid onto a clean, damp base. Repointing a cracked ridge costs less in the short term but does not add the fixings that older ridges lack, so the same cracks tend to return. It is a stopgap more than a cure. Our answer on cracked ridge mortar explains when repointing is enough, and the page on BS 5534 ridge and verge fixing covers the standard in more depth.
When a fully dry ridge is the better buy
A dry ridge suits a roof of regular concrete or clay tiles where the mortar has failed more than once. There is nothing to crack, moss or fall out, and the strip beneath can help the ridge breathe. It also comes with a set of compatible fittings, such as end caps and hip trays, so the whole line is made to work together. Fitting is quicker than bedding, so scaffold time can be shorter, and there is no waiting for mortar to cure before the weather turns. That is a real advantage in a wet spring.
The ridge still needs sound timbers and tiles that suit the system, and the old mortar has to come off first. As a national guide, Checkatrade's June 2026 repair table gives £50 to £70 per metre for dry ridge, while your own figure depends on length and access. Our comparison of dry ridge and mortar weighs the two, and the dry ridge and dry verge page gives the wider picture. Photos of your ridge and its ends are all we need to begin, and the survey that follows confirms the tile type, the timber beneath and the best fixing for the roof.
More on this in Dry Ridge & Dry Verge Systems in Crawley
Two ridge fixing questions
Is a mortar-only ridge a defect?
Not by itself. Many roofs have stood for years on mortar alone. But current guidance expects mechanical fixings, so if yours has none and the mortar is cracking, adding fixings or fitting a dry ridge is the sensible repair. A roofer can lift a tile at survey and show you what is underneath.
Do the hips need the same treatment as the ridge?
Yes, the same principle applies. Hip tiles take wind from several directions and slope away from the ridge, so they should be fixed mechanically too. Dry hip systems exist for the purpose. Ask the roofer to deal with the ridge and hips together so one fixing method runs through the whole roof.